公众号:熊猫外刊精读
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
【1.17】
1.17 每日一篇 | 熊猫外刊精读
scholarly communications:Hot air
Academic writing is getting more impenetrable
【1】academics have long been accused of jargon-filled writing that is impossible
to understand. A recent cautionary tale was that of Ally Louks, a researcher who set
off a social media storm with an innocuous post on X celebrating the completion of
her PhD. If it was Ms Louks’s research topic (“olfactory ethics”—the politics of
smell) that caught the attention of online critics, it was
her verbose thesis abstract that further provoked their ire. In two weeks, the
post received more than 21,000 retweets and 100m views.Panda Foreign Magazine
Intensive Reading:Respect for Originality, Piracy Must Be Punished
【2 】Although the abuse directed at Ms Louks reeked of misogyny and anti-
intellectualism—which
she admirably shook
off—the reaction was
also
a backlash against an academic use of language that is removed from normal life.
Inaccessible writing is part of the problem. Research has become harder to read,
especially in the humanities and social sciences. Though authors may argue that their
work is written for expert audiences, much of the general public suspects that
some academics use gobbledygook to disguise the fact that they have nothing useful
to say. The trend towards more opaque prose hardly allays this suspicion.
【3 】To track academic writing over time, The Economist analysed 347,000 PhD
abstracts published between 1812 and 2023. The dataset was produced by the British
Library and represents a majority of English-language doctoral theses awarded by
British universities. We reviewed each abstract using the Flesch reading-ease test,
which measures sentence and word length to gauge readability. A score
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
of 100 roughly indicates passages can be understood by someone who has completed
fourth grade in America (usually aged 9 or 10), while a score lower
than 30 is considered very difficult to read. An average New York Times article scores
around 50 and a CNN article around 70. This article scores 41.
【4 】From “asymmetric allylation of aldehydes” to “pneumatological and
apocalyptically eschatological foundations”,
PhD
abstracts
had
an unmistakably scholarly aroma. We found that, in every discipline, the abstracts
have become harder to read over the past 80 years. The shift is most stark in
the humanities and social sciences (see chart), with average Flesch scores falling
from around 37 in the 1940s to 18 in the 2020s. From the 1990s onwards, those fields
went from being substantially more readable than the natural sciences—as you might
expect—to as complicated. Ms Louks’s abstract had a reading-ease rating of 15, still
more readable than a third of those analysed in total.Panda Foreign Magazine
Intensive Reading:Respect for Originality, Piracy Must Be Punished
【5】Other studies of academic writing have similar findings: scientific jargon and
acronyms are on the rise. The blame does not fall solely on authors. Specialisation
and advances in
technology
require
more precise terminology and
a doctoral thesis often covers some of the most obscure research topics. With
millions of views, Ms Louks might lay claim to one of the most-read PhD abstracts of
all time. She has since posted, “I love that I have somehow equipped everyone with
new terminology and frameworks!” But surging interest in olfactory ethics aside,
the trend towards illegible academic writing stinks. Clear prose would be a breath of
fresh air.
①短语:
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
1、原文:Academics have long been accused of jargon-filled writing that is impossible to
understand.
词典:be accused of:If you are accused of doing something wrong, people say that
you have done it 被指责,被指控
例句:I might be accused of being partial.
可能会有人骂我偏心。
He could be accused of passion, but never belligerence.
可以说他很冲动,但不能说他爱挑事。
Because of my connection with the bank you could be accused of insider trading.
我在银行里做事,你可能因此被人指控盗窃内部经济情报.
2、原文:A recent cautionary tale was that of Ally Louks, a researcher who set off a
social media storm with an innocuous post on X celebrating the completion of her PhD.
词典:set off :to cause an activity or event, often a series of events, to begin or
happen 引起,引发(常指一系列事件)
例句:The court's initial verdict in the police officers' trial set off serious riots.
法庭审理这起警官案件作出的初审判决引起了严重的暴乱。
If uncontrolled, the shortage would set off a new rise in meat prices.
如果不加控制, 这种短缺会引起肉价再次上涨。
It set off a chain reaction in the international money markets.
这一事件在国际金融市场上引起了连锁反应。
3、原文:If it was Ms Louks’s research topic (“olfactory ethics”—the politics of
smell) that caught the attention of online critics, it was her verbose thesis abstract that
further provoked their ire. 词典:provoke the ire of 激怒某人
例句:The plans provoked the ire of conservationists.
该计划激怒了自然环境保护主义者。
Facebook is not the only Internet giant to provoke the ire of data watchdogs.
Facebook 并不是唯一引起数据监管者不满的网络巨头。
4 、原文:Although the abuse directed at Ms Louks reeked of misogyny and anti-
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
intellectualism
词典:reek of :If an event or situation reeks of an unpleasant quality,
it seems to be caused by or connected to that quality 明显带有,充满(令
人不快的特性)
例句:His promotion reeks of favouritism.
他的升职明显有偏向的成分在内。
The portals of the rich reek of flesh and wine while frozen bodies lie by the roadside.
朱门酒肉臭,路有冻死骨.
That man's clothes reek of tobacco.
那个人的衣服沾染着烟草气味。
5、原文:which she admirably shook off
词典:shake something off:to get rid of 摆脱
例句:I hope I can shake off this cold before the weekend.
我希望周末之前我的感冒能好。
He drove through the red lights in an attempt to shake off the police car that was
chasing him.
他闯红灯企图甩掉警车的追踪。
I was unable to shake off my self-pity.
我无法摆脱自怜自哀的情绪。
6、原文:the reaction was also a backlash against an academic use of language that is
removed from normal life.
词典:a backlash against:a strong feeling among a group of people in reaction to a
change or recent events in society or politics(社会或政治方面的)强烈反响;强烈反对
例句:Either way, the risks of a protectionist backlash against China would rise.
不管采取哪种做法, 中国遭遇保护主义反弹的风险都将增加。
Many traditional economic powers , especially European ones, are experiencing a
backlash against foreign influence.
尤其是欧洲的许多传统经济大国, 正在强烈抵制外来的东西对他们经济的影响。
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
7、原文:the reaction was also a backlash against an academic use of language that is
removed from normal life.
词典:be removed from:从……剔除;从…移除
例句:Please email us to be removed from our active list of blood donors.
假如你想把自己的名字从献血联系人名单中删去,请给我们发电子邮件。
The president could only be removed from power once free elections were organised.
总统只有在开始自由选举时才能被免职。
Reference books must not be removed from the Reading Room.
参考书不得从阅览室拿走.。
8、原文:The dataset was produced by the British Library and represents a majority of
English-language doctoral theses awarded by British universities.
词典:a majority of 大多数
例句:A large majority of people approve of the death sentence.
大多数人赞成死刑。
In Britain women are in the/a majority.
在英国,女性占多数。
9、原文:With millions of views, Ms Louks might lay claim to one of the most-read
PhD abstracts of all time.
词典:lay claim to:to say that you own something 声称…归其所有
例句:Two companies have laid claim to the design.
两家公司都声称自己拥有此项设计的所有权。
But we don't lay claim to comparable expertise in every area.
但是我们并非在所有领域都拥有这样的技术。
The company wanted to lay claim to the copyrights.
公司想要请求版权。
10、原文:“I love that I have somehow equipped everyone with new terminology and
frameworks!”
词典:equipped with:to provide a person, place, vehicle, etc. with objects that are
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
necessary for a particular purpose 装备,配备
例句:All the police officers were equipped with shields to defend themselves against
the rioters.
所有警察都配备了盾牌以在与暴乱分子的对抗中防身。
The rooms are equipped with video cameras.
房间里都装有摄像头。
They become obsessed with trying to equip their vehicles with gadgets to deal with
every possible contingency.
他们变得痴迷于给自己的车辆装备小配件,以应付可能出现的各种紧急情况。
②长难句
1、原文: Although the abuse directed at Ms Louks reeked of misogyny and anti-
intellectualism—which she admirably shook off—the reaction was also a backlash against
an academic use of language that is removed from normal life.
2、分析:本句话为although 引导的让步状语从句,从句中主语为the abuse,directed at
Ms Louks 为动词过去分词作后置定语,reeked of 为谓语,misogyny and anti-
intellectualism 为宾语。后为which 引导的定语从句,其中she 为主语,shook off 为谓语。
后为该句主句,the reaction 为主语,was 为系动词,a backlash 为表语,against an
academic use of language 为介词短语作状语。后为that 引导的定语从句,is removed 为谓
语。
3、译文:尽管对卢克斯的网暴充斥着厌女和反智主义气息,她也成功摆脱了这些攻击,但
这些也反应出大众对与现实脱节的学术语言的强烈反对。
1、原文:Though authors may argue that their work is written for expert audiences,
much of the general public suspects that some academics use gobbledygook to disguise
the fact that they have nothing useful to say.
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
2、分析:该句为though 引导的让步状语从句,从句中authors 为主语,may argue 为谓
语,后为that 引导的宾语从句,their work 为主语,is written 为谓语,for expert
audiences 为介词短语做状语,后为主句,much of the general public 为主语,suspects 为
谓语,后为that 引导的宾语从句,some academics 为主语,use 为谓语,gobbledygook 为
宾语,to disguise the fact 为目的状语,that 引导同位语从句,其中they 为主语,have 为
谓语,nothing 为宾语。
3、译文:尽管作者可能会辩解称他们的作品是写给专家学者看的,但公众普遍怀疑一些学
者使用晦涩的语言是为了掩饰他们的文章并没有真才实学。
③写作技巧:
Clear prose would be a breath of fresh air.
表达:a breath of fresh air 直译为呼吸呼吸新鲜空气,常用来表示某件事情使人耳目一
新,
给人带来新鲜感,也可以理解为一股清流。
例句:Let's try that new restaurant downtown. I heard their menu is diverse and offers
unique flavors. It'll be a breath of fresh air.
我们去尝试一下市中心的那家新餐厅吧。我听说他们的菜单多样化,提供独特的口
味。这将是会让我们耳目一新。
④背景知识:
Flesch 阅读轻松度
Flesch 阅读轻松度是衡量一段文本可读性的指标。 它以创作它的作家鲁道夫·弗莱士
(Rudolf Flesch) 的名字命名。
这种可读性测试经常用于教育中来判断书籍的难度级别。 确定文本分数时会考虑两个因
素:
句子的平均长度(以单词数衡量),每个单词的平均音节数。
这个指标的计算公式是:Flesch Reading Ease = 206.835 – ( 1.015× ASL) – ( 84.6×ASW)
其中,ASL = 语句平均长度(单词数除以语句数);ASW = 单词的平均音节数(音节数除
以单词数)。高分(60-100)表明文本易于阅读,而低于 60 则意味着内容难以阅读和理
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
公众号:熊猫外刊精读
解。 以下是分数的完整细分:
90-100 :文本非常容易阅读,11 岁的学生可以理解。
80-90 :内容以会话英语书写,易于阅读。
70-80 :总体而言,文本相当容易阅读。
60-70 :文本用简单的英语写成,可以被13 到15 岁的学生理解。
50-60 :文字相当难以阅读。
30-50 :文本很难阅读,大学毕业生最好理解。
0-30 :内容非常难读,最适合大学毕业生理解。
⑤段落大意:
【1】卢克斯的帖子引起轩然大波
【2】人们怀疑晦涩的文字是在掩盖学者并无真才实学
【3】利用Flesh 指标分析博士论文的可读性
【4】人文和社科领域近年来变得越来越晦涩,甚至可读性不如自然科学类
【5】学术写作还是应当清楚明白一些